Every empire is expansionist, hence colonial. Not just the Western ones. China is colonizing Africa and parts of Asia. Russia has colonized the entirety of Siberia. Even Iran would like to expand if it could. Waging a war against an empire can be OK, even if it is fought by another empire. Fighting Nazis in WW2 was OK. Kuwait intervention was OK. Intervention in the Yugoslavian civil war was OK. Helping Ukraine against Ruzzia is OK. Mostly because they didn’t provide the USA (and “the West”) with imperial benefits, at least not that was plannable. And the people of the European and Pacific theatres , Kuwait, former Yugoslavia, and Ukraine got (or would get) a better life out of the interventions. As opposed to Iraq and Afghanistan. The problem with those wars were that they were fought for the wrong reasons, mostly greed. It smelled from the start, given that 9/11 was obviously a Saudi plot to destabilize the West, which has been a tremendous success since. Had the USA occupied Saudi Arabia, removed the royal family, put the oil fields under UN control, and made serious efforts, not just half-assed ones, to mend the rift between Islam and the West, e.g. by ensuring that Mecca and the pilgrimage remains unaffected, that would have been a war I would have supported. Had Al Gore’s presidency not been stolen, there was a chance that the USA had gone this way, instead of the money grabbing Afghan and Iraqi wars that the MIC convinced Dubya to do.
Point is, oppose or support wars based on their premise and goals, not by who is fighting them. I am yet to see a war fought by Ruzzia that was for the good of anyone but the Ruzzian elite. China hasn’t fought wars recently, but their expansion in the Third World is as cruel as the 19th century Western colonialism was.
China hasn’t fought wars recently, but their expansion in the Third World is as cruel as the 19th century Western colonialism was.
This is completely and utterly delusional. Outrageously false. You’re clearly ignorant of the practices of Western colonialism during that era, which included literal chattle slavery. Look up conditions in the Congo, for example, where workers were frequently punished by mutilation just for failing to meet a quota. Which countries is China subjecting to anything remotely similar to those practices? You’re attempting to whitewash this past by pretending that everyone is just as cruel, when the reality is completely different. Even modern day Western neocolonialism is nowhere remotely close to the absolute horror of 19th century colonialism.
The reality is that China offers development loans, which it has on occasion forgiven, and which, unlike Western loans, aren’t conditional on agreeing to anti-worker domestic policies. It does not hold monopolies on the means of production, as is the case in many neocolonies of the West. When the old system of direct control and administration was replaced with the current system, generally, the natural resources that had been stolen through overt force remained in Western hands. This is why, even compared to Western neocolonialism, China is much better for the underdeveloped world.
But forget about China, if you’re going to whitewash the actual history of slavery and colonialism like this then I’m not interested in discussing anything further with you. Nothing comparable in scale and cruelty exists in the modern day (with the possible exception of Israel, being a holdout from “old-school” colonialism).
Yeah? Show me the pictures of “Uighur slave labor camps” with child laborers with their hands chopped off, the way the Belgians did.
Or show me pictures that provide any shred of evidence that such camps exist and weren’t invented whole cloth as propaganda. You are free to go there yourself and investigate. Nothing remotely like that exists, there is zero evidence.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Persecution_of_Uyghurs_in_China is a long list of atrocities. And of course the CCP learned to hide as much of that as they can. 19th century colonizers were not aware of information warfare, so they let the atrocities be photographed and documented. Which was of course stupid in addition to being evil. Later totalitarian systems learned their lesson, and hid this shit. Most Germans didn’t know what was going on in KZ-lagers until after the war. We still don’t have a lot of documented material on Gulags, yet it’s pretty clear they were horrible. We won’t get a clear picture of what’s going on in Uyghuria (Xinjiang) and the China-owned African mines until after the CCP falls and gets out from there. But where there’s smoke there’s fire, and China makes a lot of smoke.
So, no pictures, no evidence. Just speculation on what you think might be happening.
Why is this specific to China? We could just as easily speculate that ICE detainees are being forced to work in slave labor camps with 19th century colonial conditions. Hell, we could say the same for fucking Switzerland! Maybe they’ve just gotten really good at hiding it, who knows?
This sort of baseless conjecture and conspiracy theory nonsense has no place in a serious discussion. If you’re not going to ground your views based on evidence, and instead just going to speculate and make shit up to whitewash colonialism, then there’s no point in trying to reason with you. Your conspiracy theories aren’t based on evidence or reason so they can’t be refuted based on evidence or reason. You only believe them because they allow you to whitewash history and create a false equivalency.
Look, whataboutism doesn’t work when I am saying that “yes, every empire did/does horrible things therefore none of them should be supported wholesale like tankies do”.
You’re literally the one doing whataboutism, not me. I criticized Western colonialism and you went, “whatabout China, whatabout Russia, whatabout Iran.” And then it became clear that not only are you doing whataboutism, but it’s not even about real things that actually exist and are supported by evidence. Your response to criticism of colonialism is, “Whatabout this thing that China might hypothetically be doing?”
I’m not in Beijing, I live in the US. But thanks for putting out yet another baseless conspiracy theory. Everyone who disagrees with you about anything is a foreign agent, very sane and sensible.
“I live in the US.” That explains a lot about your inexperience about the nature of China and Russia. Let me guess, your script now makes you tell me that you have traveled to China and everything was rosy.
Also, whataboutism works like this: A claims B does Bad Thing, then B says A does Bad Thing too. I started by saying both A and B do Bad Thing, and you were banging on the table that B does not. Then I said yes they do. Then you said ahhha, but what about ICE. Which is like, yes, I did start with A and B, not just B.
Every empire is expansionist, hence colonial. Not just the Western ones. China is colonizing Africa and parts of Asia. Russia has colonized the entirety of Siberia. Even Iran would like to expand if it could. Waging a war against an empire can be OK, even if it is fought by another empire. Fighting Nazis in WW2 was OK. Kuwait intervention was OK. Intervention in the Yugoslavian civil war was OK. Helping Ukraine against Ruzzia is OK. Mostly because they didn’t provide the USA (and “the West”) with imperial benefits, at least not that was plannable. And the people of the European and Pacific theatres , Kuwait, former Yugoslavia, and Ukraine got (or would get) a better life out of the interventions. As opposed to Iraq and Afghanistan. The problem with those wars were that they were fought for the wrong reasons, mostly greed. It smelled from the start, given that 9/11 was obviously a Saudi plot to destabilize the West, which has been a tremendous success since. Had the USA occupied Saudi Arabia, removed the royal family, put the oil fields under UN control, and made serious efforts, not just half-assed ones, to mend the rift between Islam and the West, e.g. by ensuring that Mecca and the pilgrimage remains unaffected, that would have been a war I would have supported. Had Al Gore’s presidency not been stolen, there was a chance that the USA had gone this way, instead of the money grabbing Afghan and Iraqi wars that the MIC convinced Dubya to do.
Point is, oppose or support wars based on their premise and goals, not by who is fighting them. I am yet to see a war fought by Ruzzia that was for the good of anyone but the Ruzzian elite. China hasn’t fought wars recently, but their expansion in the Third World is as cruel as the 19th century Western colonialism was.
This is completely and utterly delusional. Outrageously false. You’re clearly ignorant of the practices of Western colonialism during that era, which included literal chattle slavery. Look up conditions in the Congo, for example, where workers were frequently punished by mutilation just for failing to meet a quota. Which countries is China subjecting to anything remotely similar to those practices? You’re attempting to whitewash this past by pretending that everyone is just as cruel, when the reality is completely different. Even modern day Western neocolonialism is nowhere remotely close to the absolute horror of 19th century colonialism.
The reality is that China offers development loans, which it has on occasion forgiven, and which, unlike Western loans, aren’t conditional on agreeing to anti-worker domestic policies. It does not hold monopolies on the means of production, as is the case in many neocolonies of the West. When the old system of direct control and administration was replaced with the current system, generally, the natural resources that had been stolen through overt force remained in Western hands. This is why, even compared to Western neocolonialism, China is much better for the underdeveloped world.
But forget about China, if you’re going to whitewash the actual history of slavery and colonialism like this then I’m not interested in discussing anything further with you. Nothing comparable in scale and cruelty exists in the modern day (with the possible exception of Israel, being a holdout from “old-school” colonialism).
Uyghur slave labor camps say hi.
Yeah? Show me the pictures of “Uighur slave labor camps” with child laborers with their hands chopped off, the way the Belgians did.
Or show me pictures that provide any shred of evidence that such camps exist and weren’t invented whole cloth as propaganda. You are free to go there yourself and investigate. Nothing remotely like that exists, there is zero evidence.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Persecution_of_Uyghurs_in_China is a long list of atrocities. And of course the CCP learned to hide as much of that as they can. 19th century colonizers were not aware of information warfare, so they let the atrocities be photographed and documented. Which was of course stupid in addition to being evil. Later totalitarian systems learned their lesson, and hid this shit. Most Germans didn’t know what was going on in KZ-lagers until after the war. We still don’t have a lot of documented material on Gulags, yet it’s pretty clear they were horrible. We won’t get a clear picture of what’s going on in Uyghuria (Xinjiang) and the China-owned African mines until after the CCP falls and gets out from there. But where there’s smoke there’s fire, and China makes a lot of smoke.
So, no pictures, no evidence. Just speculation on what you think might be happening.
Why is this specific to China? We could just as easily speculate that ICE detainees are being forced to work in slave labor camps with 19th century colonial conditions. Hell, we could say the same for fucking Switzerland! Maybe they’ve just gotten really good at hiding it, who knows?
This sort of baseless conjecture and conspiracy theory nonsense has no place in a serious discussion. If you’re not going to ground your views based on evidence, and instead just going to speculate and make shit up to whitewash colonialism, then there’s no point in trying to reason with you. Your conspiracy theories aren’t based on evidence or reason so they can’t be refuted based on evidence or reason. You only believe them because they allow you to whitewash history and create a false equivalency.
Look, whataboutism doesn’t work when I am saying that “yes, every empire did/does horrible things therefore none of them should be supported wholesale like tankies do”.
It’s getting late in Beijing, go to bed now.
You’re literally the one doing whataboutism, not me. I criticized Western colonialism and you went, “whatabout China, whatabout Russia, whatabout Iran.” And then it became clear that not only are you doing whataboutism, but it’s not even about real things that actually exist and are supported by evidence. Your response to criticism of colonialism is, “Whatabout this thing that China might hypothetically be doing?”
I’m not in Beijing, I live in the US. But thanks for putting out yet another baseless conspiracy theory. Everyone who disagrees with you about anything is a foreign agent, very sane and sensible.
“I live in the US.” That explains a lot about your inexperience about the nature of China and Russia. Let me guess, your script now makes you tell me that you have traveled to China and everything was rosy.
Also, whataboutism works like this: A claims B does Bad Thing, then B says A does Bad Thing too. I started by saying both A and B do Bad Thing, and you were banging on the table that B does not. Then I said yes they do. Then you said ahhha, but what about ICE. Which is like, yes, I did start with A and B, not just B.