What I don’t get is why doesn’t google use the ai summary to incentivize clicking links? E.g. first summarize, leave out extra detail and then claim that this detail can be found at the link destination
I think probably because that also undermines their ad aggregation business.
If you spent a lot of time and money on SEO how irritated would you be if you paid for ads on Google and they linked to somewhere else entirely.
We already see this being a problem on spaces where there’s a big corp on the block. I never get ads “recommended results” for True Value but I do get them for Home Depot and Lowes.
Google spent decades building up all these companies to use SEO to get traffic to their sites. New companies can’t afford ad aggregation services because the few ads they run on their sites don’t get seen anymore.
And big companies were going to be more likely to get the click anyway, but can weather the AI overview storm much easier.
I’m absolutely positive that some companies engage in both. That’s why when you search for hardware store near you you get an ad for Home Depot and an actual first result for Home Depot.
I wasn’t conflating the two, but trying to point out that their system is a two part system and AI breaks both parts.
What I don’t get is why doesn’t google use the ai summary to incentivize clicking links? E.g. first summarize, leave out extra detail and then claim that this detail can be found at the link destination
I think probably because that also undermines their ad aggregation business.
If you spent a lot of time and money on SEO how irritated would you be if you paid for ads on Google and they linked to somewhere else entirely.
We already see this being a problem on spaces where there’s a big corp on the block. I never get
ads“recommended results” for True Value but I do get them for Home Depot and Lowes.Google spent decades building up all these companies to use SEO to get traffic to their sites. New companies can’t afford ad aggregation services because the few ads they run on their sites don’t get seen anymore.
And big companies were going to be more likely to get the click anyway, but can weather the AI overview storm much easier.
Those are kind of opposites: SEO is what you do so you wouldn’t need to pay for ads.
But the idea is that Google would prefer your links to other competitors in the AI summaries. It’s not difficult to do.
I’m absolutely positive that some companies engage in both. That’s why when you search for hardware store near you you get an ad for Home Depot and an actual first result for Home Depot.
I wasn’t conflating the two, but trying to point out that their system is a two part system and AI breaks both parts.