People are not as stupid as these large centralized sites like signal keep telling you they are. Ppl figured out how to make accounts on different services, forums, and platforms since the internet began. It is no more difficult to make a matrix account, or install simpleX than it is anything else. My partner and I figured out simplex within 10 minutes.
Dessalines
- 205 Posts
- 1.6K Comments
none of this information ever leaves your client device, so
The phone number you gave to signal to sign up never left your device? Do you truly believe that?
When you send a message through signal, do you actually think “nothing” left your device?
These are all “trust me bro” claims.
Give me ssh access to their server so I can verify that this “sealed sender” is working correctly and not using the info you already gave them. We would demand this transparency of open source messengers, so why not signal?
when it doesn’t know who sent any message
They have your phone number. You gave it to them when you signed up.
which group chats you’re in
Signal wouldn’t know how to route messages if it didn’t store this info.
Signal stores, and has access to, no message metadata.
Phone numbers are the most important metadata you can give them, far more important than message content. It means your real identity / name and address. With phone numbers you can build social networking graphs: who talked to who, and when.
To be convinced of this, take a look at the client source code, and compile the app yourself.
Client source code is irrelevant here. Signal is a centralized service, you can’t verify what their US-based server is actually running (although they did go a full year without publishing any server updates at one point, until they received a lot of backlash for it).
None of this information ever leaves your phone without being encrypted or otherwise masked.
You gave them your phone number / real identity when you signed up. The most important piece of info they could possibly give them, you already did.
PRODUCT PITCH: Hey everyone, I have a great idea for a secure / private messaging service.
It’s hosted in the US, subject to its pervasive spying laws including national security letters.
Also I need all your phone numbers.
Also no you can’t host this yourself, I run the only server.
Everyone who uses signal and supports it, is falling for this pitch.
Signal clients implement the Pond protocol. As a result, Signals servers know who a message is for (obviously, how else do you get the message) but cannot know who it is FROM.
Give me ssh access to signal’s centralized US-hosted server so I can verify this (IE that their centralized DB doesn’t store).
Otherwise this is a “trust me bro” claim, considering they have the phone numbers of everyone who signed up, and are the routing service for the messages you send.
Dessalines@lemmy.mlOPto
Asklemmy@lemmy.ml•How many civilians has NATO killed in total? Looking for a list of their interventions and death counts.
2·15 hours agoYes, specifically NATO operations, not necessarily ones that NATO members took part in.
A civilian means a non-combatant.
Dessalines@lemmy.mlOPto
Asklemmy@lemmy.ml•How many civilians has NATO killed in total? Looking for a list of their interventions and death counts.
7·15 hours agoRule 1… do they think it’s racist to be against NATO now lol. Probably including “anti-white” in their definition of bigotry.
Dessalines@lemmy.mlOPto
Asklemmy@lemmy.ml•How many civilians has NATO killed in total? Looking for a list of their interventions and death counts.
2·15 hours agoNice, the top link is a good list, although it feels like there are a lot of interventions are missing.
I’ve also heard the estimates for total casualties of the US/NATO war on Iraq to be ~1M people, but that could be including other deaths related from the infrastructure collapse caused by the war.
Dessalines@lemmy.mlOPto
Asklemmy@lemmy.ml•How many civilians has NATO killed in total? Looking for a list of their interventions and death counts.
5·15 hours agoAlmost entirely overlapping, especially since many of NATO’s ops are in Africa, when it’s focus is supposed to be limited to Europe.
Dessalines@lemmy.mlto
Linux@lemmy.ml•linux-android: turn any old Android phone into a Linux desktop or a smart home server
20·5 days agoIncredible things are happening with termux.
Dessalines@lemmy.mlto
Lemmy@lemmy.ml•Not seeing comment threads unless I post a comment and get a reply.English
2·11 days agolemmy.ml seems to have a fairly low send queue to kbin.earth, but lemmygrad was behind and picked up within the last day
See if its resolved now.
Zero to racism in less than a few hours
Dessalines@lemmy.mlOPto
Lemmy@lemmy.ml•Anyone with experience using anubis on their lemmy server, have a good config?English
2·12 days agoI’m not an expert, but I think the fact that you need to set a
TARGETin anubis, IE, where does anubis send you after passing it, means that you do need separate anubis’s for each site.
Dessalines@lemmy.mlOPto
Lemmy@lemmy.ml•Anyone with experience using anubis on their lemmy server, have a good config?English
4·12 days agoLemmy has a separated UI and backend hosted on different ports, so its trivial for us to just only use anubis for the front end. We couldn’t put it in front of everything due to apps also.
Dessalines@lemmy.mlOPto
Lemmy@lemmy.ml•Anyone with experience using anubis on their lemmy server, have a good config?English
7·12 days agoYep, essentially the
botPolicy.yamlthere could be a collectively developed anubis config, based on what works best.
No probs. Why not, do they have you blocked, or did piefed code in a Cowbee filter 🤣
Dessalines@lemmy.mlto
Asklemmy@lemmy.ml•Why aren't Chinese people afraid of US companies collecting their data?
401·13 days agoThis is the right answer. The PRC doesn’t let US surveillance giants operate within their country like most other countries naively do.
























The full picture is that Signal has the most important piece of information you can give anyone online: your phone number (which means your real name and current address). Also that they’re hosted in the US and have close links to the US defense industry.