Fact is, the Lemmy ecosystem needs money to handle the growing server reqirements as more people migrate as well as the development cost of new features (I know Lemmy is OSS but the devs should still get some compensation for their effort).

Seeing how much some reddit users love awards so much that they cant stop giving money to Reddit to award posts protesting the api change, this could be a great way for users to voluntary support the ecosystem. It can be easily ignored by users not caring about them (clients could even add an option to hide them), but users liking the feature can go wild and this time the money goes to volunteers keeping this alive instead of greedy admins, power mods and investors.

Though there would be some big organization questions attached: attached:

  • Which server handles the payment? A centralized one, the one where the post was made or the one where the user giving the award account was created.
  • How will the money be shared between the Devs and the individual instances in a way that is fair but cant be abused easily.
  • BrikoX@lemmy.zipEnglish
    2·
    1 year ago

    I think it’s a distraction from the actual interactions. Same way karma is.

    I’m all for supporting instances and open source developers, but any kind of reward for a donation creates wrong incentives. Donation is called a donation because it’s a gift without expecting something in return.

    • Ulu-Mulu-no-die@lemmy.worldEnglish
      1·
      1 year ago

      I fully agree with you, karma “whoring” is a serious problem on reddit, awards could lead to the same behavior here if implemented.

      Donations are the best way to support the platform, if you want to be “visible” as donator, opencollective allows you to post a message about it, there’s also a sort of top donators page, that’s more than enough in my opinion.

  • andisent@lemm.eeEnglish
    1·
    1 year ago

    I never cared for them on Reddit and used third party tools to remove or hide them.

    I don’t like that they can be used to shop visibility.

    I would like that it gives an opportunity to fund instances but I would hope we could discover another way to do this.

  • murphys_lawyer@lemmy.worldEnglish
    1·
    1 year ago

    Could we like, not immediately talk about monetisation 1 month after leaving reddit? If you want to support your instance host, you can ask for a way to donate.

    • lesnake@lemmy.worldOPEnglish
      1·
      1 year ago

      The hard truth is that long term, we likely need another way besides donations to keep the ecosystem alive.

  • Corkyskog@sh.itjust.worksEnglish
    1·
    1 year ago

    I don’t love the awards from Reddit, but I would like to see something like this (unpopular opinion, I know). Instances need funding.

    I don’t care about what the awards are themselves, I care about the way the funding works. I would love to see the funds split in a two tiered system.

    Here is a general example of my idea. When a award is purchased it gets split into two pots. One pot is a general pot that gets disbursed to those running the instances based on whatever metrics and intervals agreed upon. The other part gets assigned to the reward itself. So in this example let’s say an award costs one dollar. 90 cents would go to the pool to be split, the other 10 cents would be tied to the award. So if you award a post on an instance it goes specifically to that instance itself. Instances could even set a percent split with community moderators of the 10 cents. That way you could fund moderators (if that ever becomes needed)

    You could even split part of the award reward with the commentor assigned to it… but that puts a weird feeling in my gut and I feel like it is a bad idea to monetize the content itself.

    There is a lot you could do with this and a lot more would need to be fleshed out, so I am just thinking out loud.

  • nxfsi@lemmy.worldEnglish
    1·
    1 year ago

    I don’t want the comments section to look like the inner cabinet of the North Korean army

  • toasteranimation@lemmy.worldEnglish
    0·
    1 year ago

    Forget useless awards, we need c̶r̶y̶p̶t̶o̶c̶u̶r̶r̶e̶n̶c̶y̶ tipping abilities baked in here.

    Edit: never mind

    • effingjoe@kbin.social
      0·
      1 year ago

      crypto is the beanie babies for this generation. Some people are going to make a lot of money but a vast, vast majority are going to be the proud owners of something worthless that they spent a lot of money on.

      • toasteranimation@lemmy.world
        0·
        1 year ago

        OK, thanks

        You don’t have to put your life savings in, just use it to send 5 bucks across the network the same way you use Venmo

        • ttmrichter@lemmy.world
          0·
          1 year ago

          I can, via AliPay or WeChat wallet, reach out and send money to anybody on the AliPay or WeChat networks in seconds.

          How long does an average Bitcoin transaction take again?

          For small transaction (under 1000RMB/~US$140) there are zero transaction fees. For small businesses (doing under 10,000RMB/mo. in transactions) there are zero transaction fees as well. After that 10,000RMB limit is reached the transaction fees cap out at about 2% (they start smaller and ramp up as transactions increase).

          What’s the transaction fee for Bitcoin transactions again?

          If fraud happens when I buy something (like a business sends fake goods, or doesn’t deliver anything, etc.) the Ali Network (or Tencent for WeChat) steps in and reverses the transaction. I lose nothing. In addition if a business was egregious in its fraud, or has a history of doing it, the Ali Network (or Tencent) can and will remove that business’ ability to, well, do business. A cancer is excised.

          What’s the recourse for bad transactions on Bitcoin again?

          Donating via Bitcoin is the dumbest single way to donate. It’s slow, it’s expensive (robbing the people you’re donating to of cash!), it’s unreliable, and it’s prone to abuse.

        • Wodge@lemmy.worldEnglish
          0·
          1 year ago

          Crypto isn’t money pal, it’s a digital commodity that doesn’t have a purpose other than to be traded. There is a reason crypto’s value is measured in actual currencies rather than it’s purchasing power, as you can’t really buy much with it.

              • toasteranimation@lemmy.worldEnglish
                0·
                1 year ago

                Ok, should I write a check? Who do I make it out to? How bout direct deposit: just give me the bank account number. Why is lemmy anti-crypto?

                “Why not just give them money?”

                Because every way to do it is trackable and cryptocurrency offers privacy-protecting ways to pay people. This should be important to this community. Nobody batted an eyelash opening their wallets to Reddit for coins, awards and nfts, but crypto is the scam? Ok

                • Quentintum@lemmy.worldEnglish
                  0·
                  1 year ago

                  Well you could always try to give cash ;)

                  Snarky remarks aside, I’m not saying crypto is inherently a scam (although I do think it is more or less reinventing the wheel). I think it’s less efficient than fiat currency at this point since you need to convert your crypto to make much use of it. I can see your point about privacy protection given that transactions and accounts are supposed to be anonymous (although I have some privacy qualms about all transactions being put onto a distributed public ledger), and anonymity can be necessary if you’re suffering from persecution. But with anonymity, how do you prove your ownership over your crypto assets should you lose access to your account, or have it stolen? That’s a very critical drawback to crypto.

  • 6mementomori@lemmy.worldEnglish
    0·
    1 year ago

    tl; dr: if you don’t want to see seas of ads, awards are the better choice, in my opinion.

    honestly, i would be fine with it. I’m not entirely sure what’s the big philosophical deal, donations are harder to get, and I’m not so sure as many people are going to voluntarily go and visit the donations page. on the other hand, if the award option is immediately there within the post, one is much more likely to give it. lemmy can simply not sustain itself on the long run solely on donations, especially considering the mass of media content that may be posted. instances can run on them for now. i would prefer them running on dumb awards than on ads instead, and the mole of ads required to make up for the money needed could be really high we’d get reddit level advertisement. hell nah. also, it incentivizes the user on posting quality content if they see the chance of shiny lemming medals, maybe.