• Reygle@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    63
    arrow-down
    3
    ·
    28 days ago

    Remember folks: If you think you see someone shoplifting food or basic supplies, no you didn’t.

    • takeda@lemmy.dbzer0.com
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      27
      ·
      28 days ago

      Yeah if someone is shoplifting something like that they doing it because they don’t have a choice.

      Anyway apparently the family claims they have a receipt for the diapers. Not that opening fire for someone shoplifting is already fucked up. Gun supposed to be used when the suspect themselves is using a deadly weapon.

      And no, jumping in front of somebody’s car who just want to flee still doesn’t warrant it. They could just run the license plates and find the person. They did this, because they wanted to kill.

    • SouthernShao@lemmus.org
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      4
      arrow-down
      67
      ·
      28 days ago

      Theft is immoral and should always be stopped. Saying I get to violate your will because it helps my well-being does not justify my immoral actions.

      • bequirtle@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        24
        arrow-down
        1
        ·
        28 days ago

        If police are gonna shoot babies for shoplifting, then I’m not gonna report shoplifting :P

          • NotASharkInAManSuit@lemmy.world
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            3
            arrow-down
            1
            ·
            27 days ago

            No. No you wouldn’t, that’s a lie, you just now said you disagreed with that concept entirely.

            You literally just said the opposite of that. The exact opposite of that. You just now said that stealing is always wrong and should always be stopped.

            • SouthernShao@lemmus.org
              link
              fedilink
              English
              arrow-up
              1
              arrow-down
              1
              ·
              25 days ago

              It should always be stopped. There’s a difference between what is objectively moral and what is subjectively moral.

              Theft is objectively immoral.

              Stealing to feed your children is subjectively moral and objectively immoral.

              Both can be true at the same time.

              The reason why theft is objectively moral is because you would never want anyone to violate your will and thus, you should never want to violate the will of another.

              • NotASharkInAManSuit@lemmy.world
                link
                fedilink
                English
                arrow-up
                2
                ·
                edit-2
                25 days ago

                Save us both time, just say you love licking boots.

                Also, the concept of synderesis, which is what you’re advocating, is theocratic social programming to appease some fake afterlife rules from a fake god. It purposely removes the idea of situational and circumstantial areas of action and implies all actions have one singular miral interpretation. You’re carrying water for Abraham with this bullshit. Your concept of faux morality can rot.

          • SectoidLexi@lemmy.blahaj.zone
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            2
            ·
            25 days ago

            You’re an anarchist but you’re against shoplifting??? Holy shit I met the most pathetic fucking loser on Lemmy and that’s saying something

            • SouthernShao@lemmus.org
              link
              fedilink
              English
              arrow-up
              1
              arrow-down
              1
              ·
              25 days ago

              You’re an anarchist but you’re against shoplifting???

              I am against theft, that is correct. Theft is immoral, yes.

              Can you tell me when theft is not immoral? When you want it bad enough?

              • SectoidLexi@lemmy.blahaj.zone
                link
                fedilink
                English
                arrow-up
                1
                ·
                25 days ago

                Yeah man you stick it to those immoral shoplifters. Better snitch to the pigs even though you oppose government but it’s fine cause of what? Boosting diapers from walmart is worse than state violence?

                • SouthernShao@lemmus.org
                  link
                  fedilink
                  English
                  arrow-up
                  1
                  arrow-down
                  3
                  ·
                  24 days ago

                  Where did I outline my own personal, subjective scale of what immoral acts were more or less heignous, exactly?

                  There is a right way to live and a wrong way to live. Murdering, stealing, raping and committing fraud is wrong. Everything else is some semblance of “right”. You and I might not agree on who you should be kind to and when, or who you should help and shouldn’t, or even how much an assailant should be punished, but that’s not the same thing as a fundamental understanding that theft is wrong.

                  Theft is always objectively wrong because you would never want to be robbed, ever. It is not logically possible for you to **WILL **to be robbed, because the second you hope someone will take something from you, the act of doing so no longer manifests as theft. If you **HAND **me $10, I did not steal it from you, but if you don’t WANT me to take that $10 from you and I do, that is theft.

                  This is higher level thinking (level 5), in psychology. Fundamentally, it is the concept of understanding that what’s ***subjectively ***right or wrong differs for different people, and in understanding that, we do not demand that you live the way I command or I live the way you command, instead, we both accept that you simply do not steal because IF either of us did not want to be assailed in that way, then we shouldn’t opt to wish it upon another.

                  Most people in the world exist at a lower level of thinking, usually around level 3. The first stages typically being pure selfishness, then an understanding that there are other people with wants and needs, then an awakened understanding that you can exert control over the wants and needs of others, and thinking that everyone is only self-interested and thus, you must be self-interested as well. This is why most third world countries exist in dictatorships, usually around the third or fourth level of thinking. The fourth level is when a general community all agrees on some set of rules. Think of a strictly religious state where the government created rules meant to prevent the bad, selfish behavior of people who only think at levels 2 and 3. This is level 4 thinking. Stealing is wrong and you won’t steal or else, and by the way, we get to decide what stealing is.

                  Level 5 starts to become more “enlightened” in a manner of speaking, where you begin understanding that your way of looking at the world isn’t the “only” way. Thinking continues evolving past this, mind you, and can still be dangerous at these upper levels, such as when you hit level 6, which is where wokeism/social justice tends to land. It’s the idea that since everyone has their own views, no views can be wrong, so for example, a woman could say that **men **are dangerous to woman, but because this level of thinking isn’t high enough yet to prevent conflict, will flat out refuse to say that illegal immigrants - who are often majority men - are dangerous to woman. If you point out the cognitive dissonance in that reasoning, it will usually lead directly to anger because it strikes a conflict within that individual’s ego that they cannot resolve. Usually they will just divert by making up some other nonsense claim that may not even be related to the original declarative.

                  But the highest tiers of thinking realize that while different subjects hold different values, that there is one fundamental cardinal attribute we all share: We do not want our wills violated. But conflict IS will violation. Maybe you and I both want the same thing but only one of us can have it. One of us has to get what they want and the other cannot. So the fundamental here is that the only “fair” way to discern conflicts of will is to do so logically. For example:

                  You already own that $10 and do not want me to take it so I should not take it.

                  Now if you take $10 from me and I take it back, you may not have wanted me to take it BUT logically, you originally violated my will to obtain that $10, so in already violating that logical enterprise of justice, I am entitled to right that wrong and recreate justice.

                  This is what self defense is, or when you imprison a murderer, rapist, robber, or fraudster.

                  Murder is wrong, KILLING, on its own, may not be. Understanding that if you try to kill my child and I try to stop you from doing so and in that attempt I kill you, I was just in killing you, even though your will was not aligned in that happening. But if your will is aligned in trying to kill my daughter, who did not want to be killed (a state set long before your desire to kill her), you are not just in committing the act.

                  This is actually fundamentally already how all societies on earth behave. In no culture ever has murder, rape, theft, or fraud been OK, but the “elite” (usually politicians) often still do these things - this is what we usually tie the word “corruption” to.

                  Corruption is a good word to use too, because it is the idea of “corrupting” the core principles of justice. You cannot murder. That is a core principle. If you find a loophole where you kill and are not punished, you are corrupting that system.

                  I hope some of this makes sense and is relative to your perspective of the conversation.

                  • NotASharkInAManSuit@lemmy.world
                    link
                    fedilink
                    English
                    arrow-up
                    1
                    arrow-down
                    1
                    ·
                    23 days ago

                    TL;DR: he loves the boot and savors the flavor every chance he gets.

                    You’re just a capitalist dog of the state, Javert, doesn’t matter how many feathers you shove up in there.

      • stringere@sh.itjust.works
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        19
        arrow-down
        3
        ·
        28 days ago

        You’re fucking vile. Go lick boots instead of polluting us with your shit take. Stealing necessities that society CAN AND SHOULD provide to all citizens is in no way immoral when corporations are by far the worst thieves.

        This report assesses the prevalence and magnitude of one form of wage theft—minimum wage violations (workers being paid at an effective hourly rate below the binding minimum wage)—in the 10 most populous U.S. states. We find that, in these states, 2.4 million workers lose $8 billion annually (an average of $3,300 per year for year-round workers) to minimum wage violations—nearly a quarter of their earned wages. This form of wage theft affects 17 percent of low-wage workers, with workers in all demographic categories being cheated out of pay.

        https://www.epi.org/publication/employers-steal-billions-from-workers-paychecks-each-year/

      • syreus@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        16
        ·
        28 days ago

        Large corporations are stealing from individuals on a grand scale. The argument is that if they aren’t being held accountable then they shouldn’t be protected under the laws they evade.

        The commenter above wasn’t clear but the popular sentiment was about shoplifting essentials from large companies, not small shops and people’s homes.

        It’s about solidarity with the poor. We don’t have to excuse the immorality but we should see that the companies that exploit us don’t deserve our help.

        • SouthernShao@lemmus.org
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          1
          arrow-down
          23
          ·
          28 days ago

          You’re talking about deeper issues here though. What you really mean is that the underlying problem is the government and how they’re in bed with big business.

          That doesn’t mean it’s OK to steal. Robin Hood - you know the story of Robin Hood, ya? Stole from the rich and gave to the poor? But he didn’t, not at all. Robin Hood was a friend of King Richard, the richest of all. He took back what the Sherriff stole from the people - which isn’t theft. You cannot steal that in which does not belong to you.

          And your claims are grand so they require grand evidence. What is an example of a large business stealing from individuals on a grand scale? Disliking your pay or disliking the cost of goods/services isn’t theft, that’s consensual adult human interaction. If you don’t like the deal, don’t consent to it. You can vote with your wallet and labor.

          • stringere@sh.itjust.works
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            15
            arrow-down
            1
            ·
            28 days ago

            Get bent apologist.

            This report assesses the prevalence and magnitude of one form of wage theft—minimum wage violations (workers being paid at an effective hourly rate below the binding minimum wage)—in the 10 most populous U.S. states. We find that, in these states, 2.4 million workers lose $8 billion annually (an average of $3,300 per year for year-round workers) to minimum wage violations—nearly a quarter of their earned wages. This form of wage theft affects 17 percent of low-wage workers, with workers in all demographic categories being cheated out of pay.

            https://www.epi.org/publication/employers-steal-billions-from-workers-paychecks-each-year/

            • barooboodoo@lemmy.zip
              link
              fedilink
              English
              arrow-up
              5
              arrow-down
              1
              ·
              27 days ago

              Replying just to remind myself to check what dumbfuck shit that moron spouts in response to this.

            • SouthernShao@lemmus.org
              link
              fedilink
              English
              arrow-up
              1
              ·
              25 days ago

              That isn’t theft.

              The notion of a minimum wage is both arbitrary and authoritarian. It is no business of the third party to tell two adults how they can trade. There is no such thing as, “losing money annually because of minimum wage laws”. You’re not cheated because someone with a badge they created themselves tells you you’re owned something because they claim to be the authority.

              Authority is fake. Government is an illusion. You’ve been brainwashed.

            • SouthernShao@lemmus.org
              link
              fedilink
              English
              arrow-up
              1
              ·
              25 days ago

              Theft is theft. What theft is, fundamentally, is when a person enacts an action upon another in which violates the will of the other within a logical order of operations as it pertains to their property.

              For example, if you find a diamond in the woods that nobody else even knows exists and you desire exclusive authority over it then you own it. You don’t own it because I say so, you own it through a logical system because it literally cannot exist in any other feasible structure that isn’t wholly arbitrary. You own it because you did not violate the will of another in order to own it, and you own it because you desire to own it.

              If someone else came along and picked up a rock that was lying next to that diamond and you do not care at all about it, then you did not own that rock to begin with and thus, the other person did not rob you in order to claim ownership over that rock.

              But if you are with that diamond and someone else comes along and thinks they deserve that diamond more than you but the only way they can manifest their desire of exclusive authority over the diamond is to engage in an action of which violates your will, they would need to steal it from you, and you cannot own that in which you’ve stolen, nor can you steal that in which you own.

              No other claim can be made rationally that dictates who should own that diamond. It doesn’t matter if the other person has 10 other diamonds and you have none. It doesn’t matter if that other person has food and you do not and that diamond could get you food. None of that matters, and you actually agree that it doesn’t matter because you already understand and act out in this world per a cardinal rule that you could never suffer another to violate your will, whatever it might be.

              This is like the golden rule but ‘The Golden Rule’ is the ethical principle of treating others as you would want to be treated, but that concept is wholly flawed, because it does not take into account that humans have conflicting wills. Maybe I want to be punched in the fact, so the golden rule would then stipulate that I get to punch you in the face. Or what if you want a beautiful woman to have sex with you, do I get to rape her, then?

              This principle is similar to the golden rule except that you have to understand that it is go unto others as THEY would want you to do to them, plus a little extra. More or less, human conflicts of wills are always contradictory and there are only two ways to resolve a will conflict, either arbitrary, or logically.

              We both want X but only one of us can have X. How do we figure out who gets X?

              Well I can murder you and take X, and that’s arbitrary because I just decided I want X more which is not a quantifiable stance. OR we understand that if I had X first I would not want you to take it from me and since you have X first, realizing this, I choose not to take it from you. That is the fundamental principle of ownership vs. theft.

              Theft is when will is violated as it pertains to ownership. Ownership is a desire to own where you did not violate the will of another to obtain exclusive authority over. it’s that simple.

              Everything else is nonsense.

                • SouthernShao@lemmus.org
                  link
                  fedilink
                  English
                  arrow-up
                  1
                  ·
                  25 days ago

                  This is nonsense though. There is no bourgeoise. Bourgeoise is a placeholder for whatever it is you decide it is. I’ve studied Marx extensively. Marx’s constructs were fundamentally rooted in a notion outlined in an older age where there were individuals who owned things like factories, and workers in those factories. Today, what constitutes as capitol could be construed as anything that can make someone money. My computer is capitol, because I make a lot of money with it. in fact, different leftists will argue this exact concept. The “movement” can’t even all agree on what socialism should start as and what the end-game of communism would actually be.

                  The notion of communism is in no small part utterly nonsensical. The spiritual concept of communism being a system without government or money, but to stipulate that is to assert a nonsense argument and shows a lack of fundmental understanding of what either government or money is.

                  Government could be fundamentally described as any relative force monopoly. If the formal government dissolved tomorrow and the people in my neighborhood got together and agreed to protect one another from others vandalizing, stealing, or doing harm to the people therein, that is a small government. If another neighboring government came with threats of violence and overtook them and forced their rules upon them, that was just a small war where one government prevailed. You cannot “do away with government”. Money is similar. You cannot do away with money. Money isn’t even real. Roughly 90 to 92% of the world’s money is actually digital - 1’s and 0’s. It isn’t real stuff, it’s basically some kind of merit that trades had happened or are promised to happen in the future. If I mow your lawn in the summer and come winter ask you to plow my driveway and you keep refusing, I’ll mentally tally how unwilling to return my favors to you are until eventually I start refusing to help you. This is money - it’s just another way of looking at it.

                  Removing money means removing hierarchy, and that isn’t possible. The mere thought that you believe communism is even a workable system in concept shows a lack of understanding of concept. There isn’t a single human alive who will not put things into a hierarchical structure of some sort based on how they feel in the moment or their fears of the future, whatever they may be.

                  If we both want X we have to figure out how X is made and either work together to make X or trade consensually with those who can make X.

                  What is bad? Murder, rape, theft, fraud. We can work together to stop the bad. That should be our goal. In doing so, we will, through proxy, reduce the problems that arise in our modern societies.

                  • homosapien@lemmy.dbzer0.com
                    link
                    fedilink
                    English
                    arrow-up
                    1
                    ·
                    25 days ago

                    An average worker generates hundreds of thousands of dollars of value a year. How much do they get paid? 60 thousand? That is wage theft

                  • homosapien@lemmy.dbzer0.com
                    link
                    fedilink
                    English
                    arrow-up
                    1
                    arrow-down
                    1
                    ·
                    25 days ago

                    individuals still own factories and workers work in the factories. You are extremly detached from the struggle of the proleteriat

                • SouthernShao@lemmus.org
                  link
                  fedilink
                  English
                  arrow-up
                  1
                  ·
                  25 days ago

                  I never said that.

                  A cop’s role should be to analyze a situation and if given probable cause, make an arrest. That detained individual is then given a trial - assuming the victim(s) wants to press charges - and if convicted of the crime through due process, punished accordingly.

                  I never once said what I felt should have happened in this particular situation. Not once. In fact, I’ve openly admitted that I do not have enough information to know what went wrong.

                  • Catoblepas@lemmy.blahaj.zone
                    link
                    fedilink
                    English
                    arrow-up
                    2
                    ·
                    25 days ago

                    If you want the cops to come deal with the alleged theft you’re not anti-government. You are explicitly describing how you want the government to function.

          • NotASharkInAManSuit@lemmy.world
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            2
            arrow-down
            1
            ·
            27 days ago

            So, because Robin Hood wasn’t the character from the stories in real life that equates to it’s never ok to steal from anyone, ever, no matter what?

            Is all violence the exact same thing to you, as well, Javert?

            • SouthernShao@lemmus.org
              link
              fedilink
              English
              arrow-up
              1
              ·
              25 days ago

              Theft is never acceptable, no. There is an objective and logical reason as to why this is. Morality simply is the concept of actions we - meaning people - should or should not commit to. Morality does not apply to nature, simply meaning that in which sits outside of the frame of those with personhood - it only applies to people.

              So the question becomes, how do we know which actions we should or should not commit to? Well, you can answer this logically, and quite simply, actually.

              You already understand that you never want anyone else to violate your will. It is in fact logically impossible to desire the violation of your own will because that in which you will is what you want. If you say one minute that you don’t want me to punch you in the face but then the next minute you’re OK with it, it is not that your will is such that you wish it to be violated, it is that your will has changed.

              And since it is not objectively possible to place the subjective in a structure of hierarchy without that hierarchy being utterly arbitrary, you cannot set value to will. For example, say there is a diamond and both of us desire exclusive authority over it. I cannot make any claims of my desire over this diamond that objectively supersede your desires. Thus, there is no way for us to mandate who deserves the diamond as predicated solely on our feelings.

              That being said, because you understand that it would never be permissible to you that I violate your will, it can never be permissible for you to violate mine. So at this juncture all we need to set is the logical standards for how a system of human conflict must work.

              Think of it like this - I’ll set up a thought experiment example:

              You are the only human being on earth and are walking through the woods. You find a diamond on the ground and pick it up. Immediately your will is to hold exclusive authority over that diamond. You want to be the one who decides what happens to it and you would be upset if the diamond became lost, damaged, or otherwise out of your control.

              Who has ownership over that diamond? Well, you do. Not because anyone said so, but because it is the only possible outcome in this scenario. You desire exclusive authority over it and there is no other human will of which to contest your will. Those are actually the two logical criteria for ownership. Anything else is just referring to some level of authoritarian justification to mandate that your desires supersede the desires of another. Basically, arbitration through might.

              Now imagine I pop into the world and see you with that diamond and I also manifest a will desiring exclusive authority over it. Now how would I obtain my will? Well, I would need to violate your will, which preexists mine. This is actually the logical order of operations of which manifests the idea of theft, mind you. If you had passed by that diamond without a second thought and it wouldn’t bother you one bit had I come along later and coveted it as my own, then you never desired ownership and thus, did not hold ownership over the diamond in the first place and as such, I did not need to do anything to another will in order to make mine manifest.

              This is why you can own something and gift it, sell it, trade it, or discard it, and the next person to hold ownership over it obtained it through moral means. Keep in mind that it is impossible to own that in which you’ve stolen just as it is impossible to steal that in which you already own. The constructs of ownership and theft require one another for the other to exist as ideas. If you can own something you’ve stolen then the very ideas of ownership and theft become arbitrary, and now we’re arguing semantics, not ideas.

              I can take something from you (like taxes, let’s say), and tell you that isn’t theft because I have a uniform on, wear a badge, have some kind of formal sounding title, or because I tell you it’s legitimate, but none of that renders the act either legitimate nor moral. Taxation is theft not because I say so, but because the cardinal essence (see Aristotle) of the idea itself mandates it.

              It does not matter if you’re starving to death for instance and you steal food from me, even if I have so much food that I could feed the both of us for 1,000 years, the act of stealing the food itself is an act of theft and every act of theft is objectively immoral because it is logically so. You would never suffer another to violate your will as it pertained to any of your possessions either, including but not limited to food.

              What you are likely doing is misconstruing your personal, subjective views of morality. You are allowed to FEEL that someone with food for both of us for 1,000 years who won’t give some to a starving person is a bad person, and there’s nothing intrinsically wrong with that. I would agree with you on that front (though there may be exceptions, such as say, someone asking for you food who already tried to murder you or your family.)

              But personal feelings do not mean it is morally correct to rob them. The logic of that sentiment is extremely nefarious and can be used to mandate literally anything, because it’s wholly arbitrary. To use the funny, silly, and stereotypical example of Hitler here, if Hitler decided that the Jews all needed to be destroyed, he is using a similar argument of emotion without logic. He is mandating that his personal, emotional, arbitrary views hold more value than the will of those he means to slaughter because he believes himself to hold greater wisdom then his victims, which is not objectively true.

              There is no such thing as the wiser man or the lesser will. To even say that you are entitled to my food for example because you are starving is to stipulate that life itself holds a level of value that is absolute, and it doesn’t. A man for example can value anything over the value of life, and all of us actually already do this. If given the choice that a random stranger die, or your child, who would you choose? Let’s make the situation even simpler, what if it were a child rapist’s life, or your child? So you already agree that life itself has arbitrary value.

              With what respect might be owed to you as a stranger on the internet my estimate is you’ve never thought high enough level about any of this as you’re still at a low-level of thinking which is predicated principally on emotion. I do not mean offense in saying that, mind, but you might want to take a step back and think your positions through carefully first.

              • NotASharkInAManSuit@lemmy.world
                link
                fedilink
                English
                arrow-up
                2
                arrow-down
                1
                ·
                25 days ago

                Fuck the idea of reading that nonsense straight to death. Way to waste that time for yourself. You’re a boot licker, we get it.

      • IzzyScissor@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        15
        ·
        27 days ago

        In America we’re innocent until proven guilty. Cops have no legal right to be judge, jury and executioner, especially over FUCKING DIAPERS.

        They’re SUPPOSED to let them drive away, write down their license plate and then get a warrant. You’ve been brainwashed into thinking shooting at alleged thieves is somehow normal. It’s not.

        These are not morally equivalent acts.

      • mrgoosmoos@lemmy.ca
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        12
        arrow-down
        2
        ·
        28 days ago

        it’s not thievery to take back what was taken from you in the first place

        • SouthernShao@lemmus.org
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          1
          ·
          25 days ago

          That isn’t theft, but you have to understand the fundamental cardinal essence of what manifests the ideas of both ownership and theft in order to understand the logical principles therein.

        • SouthernShao@lemmus.org
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          1
          arrow-down
          1
          ·
          25 days ago

          Oh my goodness, downvotes? :)

          Do people really care about that? That seems so utterly petty and ridiculous.

        • SouthernShao@lemmus.org
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          1
          ·
          25 days ago

          I agree completely, but you need to understand cardinally, what the fundamental essence of the constructs of the ideas of ownership and theft are, which I’ve outlined twice I believe, in this thread.

          If ownership is arbitrary - thus, it is whatever a ruling class stipulates, then theft is arbitrary. I, as the ruler, can simply tell you what ownership is, so I can take from you, say you didn’t own it, then declare that what I did is not theft. The state already does this universally throughout the world today in the form of taxation.

          But that is a semantics problem, not an ideas problem. Theft and ownership remain only what they CAN be logically, not what someone arbitrarily thinks they are. You cannot own that in which is stolen and you cannot steal that in which you own. To own, you require two fundamental criteria: Desire to own, and that you have not engaged in any actions of which violated the will of another within a logical order of operations as pertaining to that thing.

          Theft is any act of which violates the will of another as it pertains to property.

          In short, if I desire to own a thing nobody else desires, I own it. If you come along and want it and I do not want to give it to you, you have to rob me in order to get it. There is no alternative. Saying you deserve it more because of X, Y, or Z is irrelevant. Even if I own 10,000 years of food for example and you’re starving, this does not mean to stole your food and you’re just taking it back.

          So if you’re going to make a claim of theft, you have to be able to both support it logically, AND support it with evidence. For example, how is Walmart stealing from you? Because it won’t give you the deal you want if you were to seek consensual employment? That isn’t theft.

          If I have food and I want $100 for it and you want me to give it to you for $10 I’m not robbing you. You don’t get my property without my consent. I have to either agree to gift it to you, sell/trade it to you, or throw it away so I no longer want it whereas you claim it after. Anything other means of which you obtain exclusive authority over my property is theft.

            • SouthernShao@lemmus.org
              link
              fedilink
              English
              arrow-up
              1
              ·
              25 days ago

              But this is only your opinion, not an objective fact of life.

              Do ALL humans deserve food and water? What about child rapists? And if you say yes even to that, what about child rapists who are not incarcerated? Does the child rapist who is currently raping a child right now deserve life? If you had a gun and you were there to stop it and you couldn’t stop it without the gun, would you kill that rapist?

              I hope so, and if so, then what you’re declaring there is that you DO have limits on who deserves what and it has nothing to do with being human and everything to do with what KIND of human you are. We all do this all the time, but most people haven’t given it any level of high-end thought, so it defaults to this generic idea of “human life has value”, which is nonsense.

              SOME human life has value. Did Hitler’s life have value? Did it when he was 1 years old? How about 10? 20? Pre Nazi Germany? Post? Where’s the line? When does he stop being deserving of life? You know the answer, or at the very least you’re likely not so stubborn or stupid to think you don’t have some idea.

              And therein lies the rub. You’re saying that you - the wise and just ruler - will take from me - the sinister and selfish barbarian - because you see me as such as see yourself as ordained to make decisions you believe me incapable of making. This just makes you an unjust and unethical tyrant.

              You are entitled to NOTHING from me unless I agree, and therein lies your fundamental problem in this argument. You are not all wise and understanding of all that which is just and moral. You are a human, possibly not even as moral or educated as I am. For all we know, YOU are the barbarian in this conversation but your ego will refute that until our last typed words.

              Being able to accept that you do NOT have all the answers and that other people are NOT the barbarians so long as they don’t do as your worldview pervades is a step closer to understanding how to live an actually just and moral life. There are other ways to see and live a human life and one of those does not intrinsically have to be that other people value what you value in the manner in which you value them.

              I can see for instance, my life’s work as having more value than the life of a rapist. But it’s just work. But it’s also my life. So we’re comparing the fruits of one life to the fruits of another. Maybe my life’s work is a cure for cancer, or maybe it’s just a new alternator for a Toyota. It isn’t for you to choose how I value - my property can hold more value than a human life if I want it to, because it’s MY value.

              And you’re free to disagree with me, and so be it! So give up your money and feed and water whomever you like. I will do the same, and maybe I’ll feed more than you will, or less, but the bottom line is you do not have the right to tell me what is valuable and what isn’t. That notion is nonsensical, not to mention irrational.

                • SouthernShao@lemmus.org
                  link
                  fedilink
                  English
                  arrow-up
                  1
                  ·
                  25 days ago

                  I don’t disagree with you, but that is a subjective value structure, not an objective one. Objective values are predicated on logic. You cannot be moral and steal even from someone you think is an asshole and still be a moral actor just because you subjectively think they’re a jerk.

                  Would I steal from someone who had lots of food if it meant my children would starve if I didn’t? Oh, 100%. I know how evil I could become given the right circumstances. If there was a button that said it would wipe out 50% of the world but my baby would survive, and if I didn’t, they would die, I would press it 10 times before you finished the sentence. That act alone would make me objectively evil, and I consider myself a very good person, but that’s because I can be.

                  I’m not talking here about what we would or would not do, I’m talking about what is moral and immoral, objectively.

                  • homosapien@lemmy.dbzer0.com
                    link
                    fedilink
                    English
                    arrow-up
                    1
                    ·
                    25 days ago

                    The problem here is that you are equating walmart to the humble wumble bwissness owner that just wants to hwelp the pweople. Walmart would press that button if it meant profit margins go up by 3%.

                  • homosapien@lemmy.dbzer0.com
                    link
                    fedilink
                    English
                    arrow-up
                    1
                    ·
                    25 days ago

                    it’s not subjective. If they steal surplus value from the workers and withhold it from them, it is the workers right to get it back, right?

              • homosapien@lemmy.dbzer0.com
                link
                fedilink
                English
                arrow-up
                1
                ·
                25 days ago

                Hitlers life had the same value during his entire lifetime. I would shoot to disable (for the child rapist question) and yes, a child rapist deserves life and rehabilitation

                • SouthernShao@lemmus.org
                  link
                  fedilink
                  English
                  arrow-up
                  1
                  arrow-down
                  1
                  ·
                  25 days ago

                  You didn’t answer my questions though.

                  You dodged because you’re not stupid enough to not understand the ramifications against your ego.

                  You will either dodge entirely, or make some other quandary up like, “there’s always a non-violent way”. Which is false. Sometimes the only way to stop someone from committing an atrocity is to kill them.

                  What would you have done in the case of some of these school shootings if you were there and armed? Would you just try and talk to the shooter, who is probably undergoing some level of psychosis, who while you’re talking, is currently murdering children? Or do you shoot them to save lives?

                  If you cannot answer that question and do it honestly, just admit that. Don’t give me some spiel here about how you would find a way to win over their heart and get them to not kill kids. If that is truly your outlook then you are delusional. It’s that simple.

              • homosapien@lemmy.dbzer0.com
                link
                fedilink
                English
                arrow-up
                1
                arrow-down
                1
                ·
                25 days ago

                Human life is not negotiable and debatable. That is it. Humans deserve to live. “My property is worth more than human life” is not a respectable opinion.

                • SouthernShao@lemmus.org
                  link
                  fedilink
                  English
                  arrow-up
                  1
                  ·
                  25 days ago

                  That’s your opinion.

                  The life of a child rapist has no value - that is my opinion.

                  There is no such thing as an objective value of human life. The mere notion that you could believe that a child rapist’s life has value is not a respectable opinion to me either, and neither of us are ordained by some god to be the wiser here in what is a respectable opinion.

                  Did Hitler’s life have value? How much value, exactly? If killing him would save the lives of others, did his life have less value? If so, then you’re already agreeing that you have a measurement for human value. What about Hitler at 1 years old? 10 years? After he became the Nazi dictator? So Hitler’s life has different value levels depending on his choices? Would you kill someone else if it was the only way to save the life of your child or significant other? If so, then you are also enacting a relative and arbitrary structure of human value onto others. My guess is you already do this but wouldn’t admit it here because it would nullify your previous statement there, which would make you feel foolish.

                  So you value the way you want to value and I will value the way I want to value. And if you try to stop me from killing a child rapist who enters my home I will kill you for being evil and trying to stop me from protecting my family from evil, because in my view, that renders you too, as evil.

                  But I’m not about to go seek you out for your values. I would only use violence to protect myself, my family, or the innocent. As a good person, I believe I should not be made to suffer the existence of a rapist or murderer. Goodliness and weakness are not an intrinsic combination.

                  Also, gods don’t exist, so if your argument is related to some kind of god-being, just know I am **always **going to throw your argument out the window.

          • homosapien@lemmy.dbzer0.com
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            1
            ·
            25 days ago

            You do not have authority over other people’s lives. If they are starving, it is your duty to save them. It has been freely given to you, so freely give

            • SouthernShao@lemmus.org
              link
              fedilink
              English
              arrow-up
              1
              ·
              25 days ago

              I agree with you. If I have more than enough food and a good family is starving, I would share. We both agree here, great!

              But the problem is it isn’t just that simple, is it? What happens if someone tried to invade my home and take from my family? What if the last time I let someone into my home because they told me they were in need they tried to kill my children? Am I not also entitled to be extremely wary of those I do not know? What do I know of your motives, your world views, etc.?

              If life were this simple the world would be a wonderful place devoid of victims and perpetrators, but it isn’t. I believe wholly that virtually all human conflict arises due to a differentiation on how differing parties view the same reality we’re all apart of.

              I mean, if you believe that you have a god who wants you to kill non-believers then if I’m a non-believer how can we coexist in peace? You don’t even believe this world runs on the same constraints that I do. It’s like if one of us felt that jumping off a cliff wouldn’t not only not kill us, but would grant us boons, yet the other of us just believes jumping amounts to suicide. How do we both exist in this same space then? We cannot even agree on how reality is.

              Remember George Floyd? The man was convicted of many felony offenses, one being when he held a gun to a pregnant woman’s stomach while his companions robbed her home. He was later martyred as a shining example of black sub-culture. They’ve made statues showcasing him in angel wings in his honor.

              The man was evil. How can I coexist knowing what he did with the fact that there are people out there who believe he was good? This isn’t just a different opinion, it’s a fundamental viewpoint of righteousness and morality itself. If we cannot even agree on what’s good and what’s not, how can I trust that every person who claims they are starving is deserving of my food? EVEN if I have more than enough to go around. Maybe I want to save ample amounts for my family. Maybe I want some so I CAN give it to those in need, but I have my own ways to vet who those people are. There are roughly 10 billion people on this planet and billions of them believe the world holds some kind of “magic” - be it some kind of god, ghosts, or other form of supernatural, and no amount of evidence changes those minds at any rapid pace.

              So again, I agree with you, but it just isn’t that simple. What I DO know is this: I am a good person who wants to help GOOD people in need and condemn those who are evil. I am not religious, I am anti-government, and I believe all people deserve to be treated equally under any moral laws we might enforce. I want you to be able to live your life however you like so long as you are not harming the innocent, but you are not entitled to what I have as if you are wise and just and I am petty, stupid and cruel. EVEN if I have LOTS more than you.

            • SouthernShao@lemmus.org
              link
              fedilink
              English
              arrow-up
              1
              ·
              25 days ago

              But what’s the situation here?

              What if we know a famine is coming and so I create a food stand and sell burgers at $5 a burger to everyone and 1 billion people buy a burger from me when they could have bought something else to eat pre-famine. Now I’ve made 5 billion dollars (we’re going to greatly simplify this thought experiment) and I buy up tons of food.

              How did I obtain all of that food? Well, 1 billion people consented to a trade with me for burgers in exchange for money. So now what if those people all get together and say, we want you to give us 50% of your food!

              Well, why the hell did you all consent to $5 a burger then? You could have literally negotiated it at $2.50 a burger and then saved the other $2.50, couldn’t you? Or why didn’t you all buy $1.00 salads at the other shop instead and save up the remaining $4.00? Do you understand that to demand what I have now is to simply say you consented to $5 then decided to show back up with a mob and threaten me unless I sold it for $2.50? And what if I wouldn’t have consented to $2.50 so I stopped selling burgers and went out of business? Then everyone could have just got that $1 salad instead and saved that money for future food.

              So now we’re in a famine and people are without food and I’m to blame because I have food? I need to give everyone back because everyone changed their mind due to future circumstances?

              And hell, I would personally be more than happy to help GOOD people in need, but how do I know who’s good? Would you feed the child rapist if you had the food? Would you let them into your home and feed them? Or just expect someone else to do all of that for you and assume you’re playing your part because you vote and get taxed?

              So some people don’t deserve your food even if you have an abundance, do they? And what if I let someone into my home and they don’t just take what I offer, but they try to take all of it? What if they try to kill me and my family? Should I trust the next person who comes by asking for food? If a mob shows up at my door with pitchforks and demands - the same ones who CONSENTED to pay me for my burgers before, do I just open my doors happily?

              You’re simplifying a hugely complex construct. Life isn’t as simple as this and people aren’t as trustworthy as this. I’d see all rapists and murderers dead. The ONLY reason I am actually NOT in favor of the death penalty is because I do not want a single innocent person murdered for something they did not do. If we had an unequivocal way of knowing rapists and murderers committed the acts, I would say immediate death penalty for each and every one without question.

              Not all human life has the same value. We all know this and we all live this way, we just don’t want to think about it and certainly don’t want to talk about it in public because it’s not the politically correct thing to talk about.

                • SouthernShao@lemmus.org
                  link
                  fedilink
                  English
                  arrow-up
                  1
                  ·
                  25 days ago

                  And that would be your choice, but then what? Do you let them share a bed with your child? Or do you even have limits? Do you detain them and cage them after? Do you just let them go free? What if it was your child they raped?

              • homosapien@lemmy.dbzer0.com
                link
                fedilink
                English
                arrow-up
                1
                ·
                25 days ago

                better scenario:

                I create the famine to sell more burgers, I blow up the salad stall and kill it’s owner, and lobby the government to make me the only authorized food seller and I buy all the other food places.

                I can’t make billions of burgers myself, so I employ wage slaves and take 90% of their surplus value, only giving them 10%

                They can’t work anywhere else as anywhere else either doesn’t exist or has the same policies as us for profit™️

                • SouthernShao@lemmus.org
                  link
                  fedilink
                  English
                  arrow-up
                  1
                  ·
                  25 days ago

                  This is moving the goalpost. Do you agree that if I have enough food for 1000 years and I got it morally then you are not justified in taking it from me even if you are starving? Are you only saying you can have it if I took it from others? These are two completely different things here.

                  No rational and moral individual is going to argue that if someone stole food from everyone then those “everyone” shouldn’t be valid in taking it back. Nobody believes that.

                  The big problem there is there are a lot of arguments over what constitutes “ownership”.

      • NotASharkInAManSuit@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        2
        arrow-down
        2
        ·
        27 days ago

        They’re talking about stealing from corporations. It’s a god damned Walmart. This isn’t about enabling your victim complex.