Is there a way to make sure people can accept criticism? Or will they always feel offended?
edit after the first few comments: this is about criticing others i collaborate with in online communities where we predominantly communicate through text
There is no fool proof way. Good conversationalists pull together a large number of factors, such as the length of time they have known someone, that person’s general behaviour and demeanour, etc. to figure out how a person will react. There’s a subtle way to be nice while providing feedback that many of us can sense automatically.
If this is not you, due to autism or lack of social practice, you can probably just say things point blank. E.g.
“Hey I’ve got some feedback on your actions which I want to give you but I don’t want to make you upset so I’m not sure how. Is it alright if I provide my opinion?” - then the feedback if they say yes - then sometimes it’s nice to reiterate the first bit.
If you’re in a community of neurodivergent people, or just anyone I guess, you should also get familiar with tone tags, which help to make it clear the sense that you are saying something in. Common examples are “/s” for sarcasm, “/j” or “/jk” for joking, “/hj” for half joking, “/gen” for genuine, “/silly” for silly, “/pos” for positive, “/neu” for neutral, “/neg” for negative, “/lh” for lighthearted.
Give feedback, not criticism. Avoid using the word “you” as much as possible – that is usually interpreted as an attack and shifts them into the defensive. Talk about the effect that their actions or choices had on you. Focus on your experience and try to put it to words. Use I-statements (as opposed to you-statements). Name your feelings and needs in the situation. Feelings and needs are universal, so you’re much more likely to connect and get through to them.
These are some of the principles of Nonviolent Communication. If you want to dig in (much) deeper, read the book by Marshall Rosenberg. Good luck!
By making it constructive. Don’t just point out what is wrong, show them a path to get to the right place.
Also, are you in a position where it’s expected that you give feedback? If not, might be worth leading with, “Hey, are you open to a small bit of feedback on […]?” Or just learn to keep it to yourself. Things don’t have to be perfect, and your way isn’t necessarily the only way.
Basically, there’s no simple answer.
Careful here though; people often react negatively to being told how to do something they’ve already been tasked with doing, because it looks a lot like micro managing or taking over.
Two things that help are: asking for help yourself, and making the suggestion for how they should do Y in the context of how you should do X, asking them if they think that approach would be a good idea.
Then you come across as approachable, demonstrate collaboration by example, and get to sneak in the right way to do things so it’s on their mind while they’re trying to find their own solution.
Just start your message with “No offense”.
No offense, but that’s the stupidest advice I’ve ever heard.
No offense, but that really wasn’t a good way to say no offense, buddy.
Damn, is this is the default sub for unrecognized autism?
As an a peer-reiewed autistic person, the answer is no. Though if you are required to, you are supposed to precede and follow the criticism with a compliment to make a jellyfish sandwich which hopefully only stings after you’ve left the room.
i may be a sub but i think i recognize it
For irl criticism, the biggest things are 1 making sure it the appropriate time and place, and 2 is it appropriate for ME to be giving this feedback or am I being nosy? It may be legitimate for them to push back and I am the one not taking that feedback appropriately.
Online both are harder. DMs tend to be better than in public, and if it’s not something solicited or directly affecting you, maybe it’s best to let it go. Especially if you don’t have a prior relationship with the account online.
The more narcissistic they are, the worse they take it. The more people enable them, the more narcissistic they get.
😬
Context is everything.
Is it the place, the time, is it actionable, is it between their area of responsibility, are there other factors out of their control that conditions their actions, are they acting in good or bad faith, is it a matter of attitude, skill, resources, willingness, priorities, awareness, assumptions, incorrect information, and a whole slew of conditionals I’m forgetting right now.
You mention you all have the same goal. Start by challenging said assumption in yourself. That shall clue you in on where you need to start the conversation. Find the logical reason why they are acting in a way you see as erroneous. Because you think is wrong, but obviously they don’t. Few people do things they think are wrong on purpose. Ask them, and try to see the issue from their perspective. Then it will be obvious how you should address the issue.
PS: always be kind and empathetic. Address actions and consequences, not character and personality. Remember, unless you’re psychotically talking to an LLM, there’s a human on the other side of the screen. Just like you.
wow, now that is awesome advice! thank you!
Criticism is better received when it’s about an action or outcome, not a person. Saying “you” a lot puts someone on the defensive. Focus on a specific event and its effects.
No. You can’t. They will be offended 95/100 times.
If you come off as accusatory then people will respond defensively. Conflict virtually always takes two.
When I felt disrespected I pulled the guy aside and asked if I had unknowingly offended them and what I can do to make it right. Turns out his behaviour had nothing to do with me. He apologized and acted extra nice towards me from there on.
Oi fuckface, stop doing that, it is shit. Do it like this.
Very effective, it may offend them, it may not.
sounds like a 50/50 chance to me
Oi fuckface
Sometimes i miss australia.
I try to couch criticism and disagreement with something I liked or agree with first, or that I repeat back, paraphrasing to the person how I understood their argument, before I launch into the criticism. Using passive voice to describe the counterpoint or negative consequence instead of accusing your message recipient directly can avoid defensive knee-jerk reactions. I think you want to invite reflection and a serious consideration of your argument or criticism, so that’s what I would do.
It’s pretty easy when the person you’re criticizing is mature.
“Doing A causes B.” This identifies the action and explains the results of that action, without criticizing the person at all. It doesn’t even directly criticize the action, just points out an undesirable result.
You could also express “I think that doing A causes B, but I’d like to know more about whether that’s true.”
By using “I think that”, you express that you have some doubt in yourself and that you accept that you could be incorrect, which indicates that if a person disagrees with you it’s not a huge problem. Expressing that “I’d like to know more about whether that’s true” reinforces that indication, and additionally expresses that you are inviting discussion about your thought because you are interested in becoming more “correct” (I considered suggesting to use “I’d like to be more certain about that”, but if you are incorrect in your thinking then becoming less certain might lead to you becoming more correct: “sometimes a little uncertainty isn’t all that bad”).
As an alternative to expressing doubt, you could express confidence by using words like “I am 100% confident that” so that you can express that you would probably not become more happy if someone disagreed with you. If you don’t express any information about how comfortable you are with someone disagreeing with you, someone who does disagree with you might be uncertain about how you’ll react to an expression of disagreement, which will surely lead to them being less comfortable and will surely make it harder for them to choose how/whether to inform you that they disagree with you.
I’d like to note that if you always express doubt by using “I think that” then it will become less interesting as time passes: if people notice that you always express doubt then they’ll surely begin to “skim” your messages by skipping reading “I think that” any time you write that, so at some point you might as well just save everyone time and stop writing that. Therefore, I try to provide more specific information about my confidence level by using different vocabulary, like “I suspect that” (to express low confidence) or “I expect that” (to express relatively high confidence, while still expressing that I would be surprised but not angry if I turned out to be incorrect) or “It’s surely true that” (to express that I have extreme confidence (to the point that I am assuming that what I’m expressing is 100% true), while still avoiding any explicit expression that I would be angry if someone disagreed with me (if I expressed “It’s surely true that the store closes at midnight” and it turns out that it closed one hour before midnight, I wouldn’t be angry at the person I said that to since they didn’t contribute to me being incorrect)).
I realized that I didn’t mention an alternative for “I think” that I use often: “It seems”. To me, “It seems” is quite similar to “I think”, though “It seems” expresses more confidence (it expresses that a thing definitely has a particular quality, though that quality is only “seeming” (having an outward appearance), which doesn’t comment on the reality of the situation since how something “seems” is only related to someone’s initial interpretation of the overall outward appearance of that thing), and “It seems” also expresses that your opinion is influenced by an actual observation (I could say “I think that Berlin and Moscow are close to each other” even if I don’t have any relevant experience about that topic, but if I say “It seems cold today” it expresses either that I have actually been outside to experience the weather or at least that someone has reported information about today’s weather to me).







