This line of thinking is straight-up just eco-fascism. Claiming the solution to the world’s problems is the extinction of our species is equivalent to claiming the solution to depression is suicide.
Obviously we should do everything in our power to stop doing the terrible things humans have done in the past, and to clean up the mess we’ve already made, but the solution is progressing as a species, not going extinct.
I wish people would stop acting as if we’re some kind of foreign invader or pest on the planet. We’re part of nature as much as any other living thing, and we have the unique ability to be protectors of the places we inhabit.
The false dichotomy between humans and the rest of the environment is the whole reason we’ve made such a mess to begin with. As long as we view ourselves as “other”, as different, we will keep making the same mistakes we’ve been making.
I take it you view anti-natalism as eco-fascism, even if it ideologically doesn’t even bring up environmental damage?
I agree that humans are part of nature, and that viewing humans as a plague on nature is dumb. I however do not see the positive of continuing our species, for the very individual’s within it. None of us consent to being born, and if only 1 in a million find their existence to be undesirable (and its a way way worse rate than that) then giving birth to a single person is rolling the dice on bringing about unjust suffering and is unethical.
I don’t view anti-natalism as inherently eco-fascist, no. I said what I did because the person I was responding to directly brought up environmental damage.
That said, I don’t personally agree with anti-natalism as applied on any level larger than personal. There is no world in which a fetus of any species could ever consent to being born. Does that mean all life should cease to exist on principal?
I still believe that a person’s reproductive choice should always be their own. If that leads to the extinction of our species, then at least it’s what we collectively chose for ourselves. But I find it frankly insulting to women who want children to act like bringing them into the world is a morally unjust thing to do. In the same way, I view it insulting to women who wish to remain childless to act like not having children is morally unjust.
I truly feel there should be no moral imperative for anyone to have or not have children.
There is no world in which a fetus of any species could ever consent to being born. Does that mean all life should cease to exist on principal?
Yes. (Under ideal conditions at least, life exists already though, I’m not a believer in efilism)
I still believe that a person’s reproductive choice should always be their own. If that leads to the extinction of our species, then at least it’s what we collectively chose for ourselves. But I find it frankly insulting to women who want children to act like bringing them into the world is a morally unjust thing to do. In the same way, I view it insulting to women who wish to remain childless to act like not having children is morally unjust.
Understandable from a women’s rights perspective, if you think that is what this is. However, my issue isn’t with whether specifically a woman chooses to have a child. Men can also want children and its also their choice as to whether they want to impregnate a woman. At least in so far that they do or do not engage in preventative methods with sexual activity.
I find both equally disagreeable, ethically.
I truly feel there should be no moral imperative for anyone to have or not have children.
What’s actual facism is how the human race has destroyed this planet.
Your suicide example is a false equivalency. I think this one works better in a personal example. Two parents realize they have something in their genetics that if they have a child, it could end up suffering. Instead they do the responsible choice and decide not to have the child. My example doesn’t involve violence and is about prevention.
Humans have been different from other animals since the cognitive revolution. Once they figured out using tools like fire to dedtroy entire forests to make hunting easier, we are already different then all other animals.
we have the unique ability to be protectors of the places we inhabit
How does that make the billionaires get richer, though? Because if it’s not going to make them richer they will do everything thing in their power (which is immense) to actively stop it. (And I domeaneverything.
Oh if you think the problem is only billionaires, it must seem easy to solve. Billionaires are rare enough that they collectively own a small amount of wealth. Kill them all and little changes unfortunately. Millionaires are super common so they collectively own much more. Largely it’s just old people retiring who own everything. Old people own well over half of everything and they need their investments and retirement funds to keep going up.
The billionaires are the face of this evil, but they’re only the tip of the iceberg.
What are you on about? At this point in the US being a millionaire is a necessary prerequisite of retirement. You can obtain that just by working a job.
Being a billionaire necessitates screwing many, many people over in order to get your wealth. And if you think billionaires aren’t in possession of that large a share of the wealth, need I remind you that Elon Musk alone has nearly 900,000x the amount of money as a millionaire. That gap is as far apart in orders of magnitude from being a millionaire as a being a millionaire is from someone having a total life savings of $1.
Not to mention, the top 1% of people (which admittedly includes multi-millionaires in the order of hundreds of millions) collectively hold more wealth than the other 99% combined. Just the billionaires collectively hold around 15% of the global GDP. That’s hardly a “small amount of wealth”.
Yeah, I like to say that “we can’t just go to space, we have to bring the earth (materials, food, air), and the sun (power, heat) with us. We are not inseparable from our environment because we are our environment
This line of thinking is straight-up just eco-fascism. Claiming the solution to the world’s problems is the extinction of our species is equivalent to claiming the solution to depression is suicide.
Obviously we should do everything in our power to stop doing the terrible things humans have done in the past, and to clean up the mess we’ve already made, but the solution is progressing as a species, not going extinct.
I wish people would stop acting as if we’re some kind of foreign invader or pest on the planet. We’re part of nature as much as any other living thing, and we have the unique ability to be protectors of the places we inhabit.
The false dichotomy between humans and the rest of the environment is the whole reason we’ve made such a mess to begin with. As long as we view ourselves as “other”, as different, we will keep making the same mistakes we’ve been making.
I suppose there’s several solutions tbh
I take it you view anti-natalism as eco-fascism, even if it ideologically doesn’t even bring up environmental damage?
I agree that humans are part of nature, and that viewing humans as a plague on nature is dumb. I however do not see the positive of continuing our species, for the very individual’s within it. None of us consent to being born, and if only 1 in a million find their existence to be undesirable (and its a way way worse rate than that) then giving birth to a single person is rolling the dice on bringing about unjust suffering and is unethical.
But yeah, Human’s aren’t a plague.
I don’t view anti-natalism as inherently eco-fascist, no. I said what I did because the person I was responding to directly brought up environmental damage.
That said, I don’t personally agree with anti-natalism as applied on any level larger than personal. There is no world in which a fetus of any species could ever consent to being born. Does that mean all life should cease to exist on principal?
I still believe that a person’s reproductive choice should always be their own. If that leads to the extinction of our species, then at least it’s what we collectively chose for ourselves. But I find it frankly insulting to women who want children to act like bringing them into the world is a morally unjust thing to do. In the same way, I view it insulting to women who wish to remain childless to act like not having children is morally unjust.
I truly feel there should be no moral imperative for anyone to have or not have children.
Yes. (Under ideal conditions at least, life exists already though, I’m not a believer in efilism)
Understandable from a women’s rights perspective, if you think that is what this is. However, my issue isn’t with whether specifically a woman chooses to have a child. Men can also want children and its also their choice as to whether they want to impregnate a woman. At least in so far that they do or do not engage in preventative methods with sexual activity.
I find both equally disagreeable, ethically.
Do you think having children is harmless?
Not only that.
They’re making innocent people responsible for things that unrelated people did years ago (and still does today to one or another extent).
That’s a genetic fallacy, and a form of non sequitur.
That is, how it feels, when your life is in ruins, and there is no hope for things to ever get any better.
What’s actual facism is how the human race has destroyed this planet.
Your suicide example is a false equivalency. I think this one works better in a personal example. Two parents realize they have something in their genetics that if they have a child, it could end up suffering. Instead they do the responsible choice and decide not to have the child. My example doesn’t involve violence and is about prevention.
Humans have been different from other animals since the cognitive revolution. Once they figured out using tools like fire to dedtroy entire forests to make hunting easier, we are already different then all other animals.
How does that make the billionaires get richer, though? Because if it’s not going to make them richer they will do everything thing in their power (which is immense) to actively stop it. (And I do mean everything.
Billionaires are temporary.
They do not think so, and they’re very loud.
Kings thought the same thing.
I am unfortunately well aware. I don’t want humans extinct, but man I would love if billionaires would just fuck off and die already.
Oh and corporations aren’t people. The world would absolutely be better off if they didn’t exist.
Based.
💯 💯 💯
Oh if you think the problem is only billionaires, it must seem easy to solve. Billionaires are rare enough that they collectively own a small amount of wealth. Kill them all and little changes unfortunately. Millionaires are super common so they collectively own much more. Largely it’s just old people retiring who own everything. Old people own well over half of everything and they need their investments and retirement funds to keep going up.
The billionaires are the face of this evil, but they’re only the tip of the iceberg.
What are you on about? At this point in the US being a millionaire is a necessary prerequisite of retirement. You can obtain that just by working a job.
Being a billionaire necessitates screwing many, many people over in order to get your wealth. And if you think billionaires aren’t in possession of that large a share of the wealth, need I remind you that Elon Musk alone has nearly 900,000x the amount of money as a millionaire. That gap is as far apart in orders of magnitude from being a millionaire as a being a millionaire is from someone having a total life savings of $1.
Not to mention, the top 1% of people (which admittedly includes multi-millionaires in the order of hundreds of millions) collectively hold more wealth than the other 99% combined. Just the billionaires collectively hold around 15% of the global GDP. That’s hardly a “small amount of wealth”.
Yeah, I like to say that “we can’t just go to space, we have to bring the earth (materials, food, air), and the sun (power, heat) with us. We are not inseparable from our environment because we are our environment
Alan watts has a great little talk on this
https://youtu.be/k9IH9F-IiU8