I read “Cyberattack” as “Cybertruck.”
Not a fan of U2, but this move made me like them even less.
Not a fan of Apple either, and I wonder how they agreed to this (given how it turned out).
NEVER FORGET
I delete this damn album off my account multiple times a year and that damn thing always finds a way back on there!!
You’re there, rocking out to your music collection suddenly its “what the FUCK is this shit???” and you know. You know.
Bono’s red credit card scheme failed. That’s why he agreed to this. Desperate times and such.
There was so much backlash that Apple had a procedure to remove the album from your account.
It was such a shit album too.
Uno, dos, tres, catorce!
Iirc it wasn’t even deletable until people got really upset about it and they changed how things worked.
It was crazy that Apple thought that was a good idea. I thought someone had started buying music on my account because there was just zero messaging about it.
It was actually an accident. They wanted the album to be free for everybody who wanted it but weren’t trying to force it on anybody. They decided, based on the way the iTunes Store worked at the time, the easiest way to do that would just be to mark the album as “purchased” in everybody’s account. Unfortunately they overlooked the fact that most people’s settings were to automatically download all purchased music. So they ended up pushing the album onto most customers’ devices by default
There were stories of people on metered mobile plans who got royally shafted on excess data charges, and naturally all the rabid Apple fanbois mocked them for not having their phone configured correctly.
What’s worse is that in many cases the cheaper data plans were/are very predatory in terms of excess charges, so it was mostly the people who could only afford the cheapest plan, who were getting hit with the biggest bills.
That’s not really how Jobs described it on stage. Source: I’m old and watched it live.
That is…not how I remember this. Seems like a weird detail that I would miss that it was completely an accident. I also remember the album being impossible to delete until backlash happened and they allowed it. If what you are saying is true, does that mean if I bought any songs back then, I wouldn’t have been able to ever delete them? Sus af claim…
They say it was an accident. I find it more likely that someone in the middle of the chain said it was a bad idea and gave the obvious reasons why and then the dipshit at the top of the chain got butt-hurt that someone questioned it and said “Do it anyway.”
At least that’s been my experience with any company with more than 3 people.
Maybe nitpicking here, but:
The album wasn’t impossible to delete, the “purchase” was. You were able to remove the downloaded files from your device, but the album would remain listed in your purchase history. It wouldn’t be played if you had removed the files, but when you viewed your purchase history it would be in there, even if you hadn’t downloaded the album. You could hide the purchase from your purchase history, but then it would still be listed under hidden purchases. This is what people took offence with and what Apple later rectified by releasing the “soi-remove” page. It’s generally impossible (or at least it was at the time) to remove any purchase from your purchase history, you can only hide them.
Thanks for explaining. Those are details I never knew! People must have been wrong at the time because I remember people complaining about how much space it took up.
Well they weren’t wrong necessarily. The album was a couple hundred MBs, but phones had a lot less storage space back then. There were people who couldn’t use their phones to take pictures anymore after this download, which is a horrible user experience of course. Add to that that not all users knew how to remove music (especially people who never used iTunes) and it’s evident why people were pissed. Most people were just pissed off because they didn’t ask for this or they hated U2’s music. And rightfully so, if you ask me.
I mean they must have been about not being able to delete it. Definitely remember people complaining they couldn’t delete it and it took a lot of space.
Best engineers you can hire with money did this. And people still believe neuroslop is good.
Engineers have far less control over that process than most people realize. Management, accounting, and the execs that signed off on it are to blame. Every time.
Oh I’m sure an engineer thought about that, reported it, but the effort involved in a new “add to library but don’t automatically download regardless of user setting” did not fit Bono’s timeline
Or, get this, even good engineers make big mistakes sometimes. We don’t get to blame managers for everything
Yes, generally that’s true. And also many managers are engineers who moved into a role. I find it unlikely though in this case “add an album to every single Apple account” went through a proper engineering/spec audit and missed what is almost certainly the most blaring edge case
So either it was intentional, which is more likely in either scenario of “if we do this x will happen without us spending engineering time on preventing x so let’s just do it” or “we want x to happen, that’s the goal”.
The alternative is it never went through a proper audit/spec and was given as a direct task, either in an admin user interface or “run this db migration to add this album to everyone’s account” which is a failure in process or a deliberate circumvention of said process.
Or they designed it to have plausible deniability that their back end was not spaghetti coded.
I don’t think there was any engineers involved even. It was just a change by the non-technical apple music administrators
I don’t think just marking it as purchased makes it better really. It still shows up in the library and looks like someone is buying songs on your account.
Only offline devices like iPod wouldn’t immediately synchronize the album for obvious reasons. It showed up in all libraries as soon as they synced with Apple, say, when launching iTunes. If auto download was off, the files would still stream when clicked and then live locally.
As for if the files immediately became present on all devices validates or invalidates the meme, that is an argument for the Council of Meme Lords.
Nice try, Bono. (Joking, not personal attack.)
and no way to delete it
With or Without You.
But mostly without U2
Not going to lie, The Joshua Tree was a great album.
Eh, it’s fine.
Younger people can’t conceive of this now, but U2 was once the young, fresh alternative to soulless arena rock and equally soulless New Wave synth pop. “Sunday Bloody Sunday” and “New Year’s Day” (from the album “War” in 1983) were unlike anything else on American radio at the time. Their later '80s albums were good, but they were already signaling the start of the process whereby U2 was disappearing up their own assholes, which culminated in a fucking Spider Man musical (far worse than the at-gunpoint album forced onto people’s phones). It’s hard to accept that those idealistic young men turned into tax-dodging cunts, but that’s the nature of getting old, I guess.
I was a big fan of their 80s stuff and even went to their concert after the release of “How to Dismantle an Atomic Bomb.” The mid-90s stuff was a bit weird but I could still dig it. But with the Apple shit I feel like they are the poster children of selling out. I saw an NPR article that made the claim that their newest album is a return to form. Press X to doubt.
I wouldn’t be surprised if they just let AI make their new album for them. I wouldn’t even be surprised if they’ve actually been dead for a couple of years.
The first time my eMachines touched the internet, the surprisingly excellent RealJukebox was irreversibly replaced with RealOne, which is hot garbage. This has unironically shaped my opinions on software over the following quarter-century.
My friend got an e-machine.
The one that was made to look like the first iMac.
The cd drive malfunctioned while installing a game and caught fire. It was pretty cool.
The emachine was not cool.
For me it was in 2000 when my Napster account got locked because some cunts used the legal backdoor.
I like that album
Wish I could say the same about the 4-or-more-word album title era. I’m desperately waiting for a remastered/remade version of Pop or at least some Pop demo tapes à la How to Reassemble.
u2 succccckkkkkssssss
OMG thank you.
Smug, holier-than-thou singer, douchenozzle guitarist who has the balls to call himself “the edge” then proceeds to play the SAME FUCKING RIFF on every song. I’d like to push them all over the edge onto a lot of pointy rocks.
I do not understand the worship of these guys. They had a moment (being generous, I don’t care for anything they’ve done) and just wouldn’t fucking go away. No seriously, that’s enough you can go home now, please go. dingadingadingadingadingadingadingadinga and eyes closed screeching into microphone.
JFC
I’m not impressed by the people who set up and maintain The Edge’s gear, than the man himself
I’m with ya. Feel closeted about this since they are so ubiquitously popular. I don’t have any hatred towards them, but man their music just doesn’t resonate with me at all. I’ve even seen Bono live and still have not caught the bug.
Are they still popular? Or is it just that people fairly remember their early stuff as being good?








